Blogging, Journalism and Credibility: Battleground and Common Ground Conference
From dKosopedia
Contents |
About This Page
This page is intended as a central place to gather information on the "Blogging, Journalism and Credibility: Battleground and Common Ground Conference" being held at the Berkman Center for Internet and Society at the Harvard Law School on January 21 and 22, 2005. Over the past few weeks a number of questions have been raised about this conference - the choice of participants, the backgrounds of the chosen participants, their agendas and the overall goals of the conference. I'm not satisfied that those questions have been answered. This page is my attempt to get those answers and to come up with further questions. I hope people will help.
The conference has a blog, and I've used it to gather the initial info. However due to the questionable actions by the conference participants to date, I think it's important to further investigate the information they've provided.
Another site gathering info on conference participants is here.
About the Conference
Live IRC discussion and transcripts will be provided on freenode.net in #webcred and #webcredtrans, respectively. Questions and comments posted in #webcred will be relayed to the speakers.
The initial info for this section comes from the "About the Conference" entry on the conference blog.
Due to limited financial resources this conference cannot accommodate large numbers of people. But it will be webcast live and there will be an IRC so that people can participate remotely in the discussion. All conference sessions and all online discussion will be completely public and on-the-record.
Our shared motivation for convening such a conference is our conviction that the world of journalism is being transformed by blogging, and that - similarly - the blogosphere is evolving and being transformed in the process. There can be no question that the phenomenon of blogging, especially blogs focused on politics and public affairs, has changed the way information becomes front page news. The examples of Trent Lott, the Swiftboat allegations and the disputed CBS documents come immediately to mind. In each of these cases, bloggers shaped the news, and the influence of blogging will only increase.
To both journalism and blogging, credibility is essential. What are the areas of common ground shared by these very different approaches to handling news and information? Can journalists who also blog do their work without conflicting standards? Might bloggers adopt standards and a transparency that will elevate their credibility? Our purpose is to bring together a small group of smart and thoughtful people to ponder these and other related issues, which will result in a published report and - we hope - will mark the beginning of an on-going and very important dialogue.The conference will take place on the 21st and 22nd of January, 2005. More detailed info on the schedule can be found here.
The Participants
The participant list comes from the "The Participants" entry on the conference blog.
The Career section is the information given on that page. It seems to be kind of hit-or-miss info on the participants.
- Anderson, Faye
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Counting on Democracy, writer, producer, and policy consultant
- Background Info: (from the itvs.org counting democracy page) A noted political analyst, Faye M. Anderson is the former national correspondent for PoliticallyBlack.com. During the first Bush administration, Anderson was a political appointee with the Employment Standards Administration of the Department of Labor. Her writings have appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal and she was a frequent guest on Politically Incorrect with Bill Maher. Anderson is a member of the National Coalition on Black Civic Participation's Election Reform Task Force. She served on the steering committee of African-American Unity 2000, a national coalition of 80 grassroots organizations that was responsible for the higher than expected black voter turnout in the 2000 elections. Previously, Anderson was a national vice chairman of the Republican National Committee's New Majority Council and a member of the boards of the Ripon Society and the Ripon Educational Fund. She formerly served as executive director of the Council of 100, a national network of African American Republicans.
PoliticallyBlack.com is a dead link. Courtesy of http://archive.org/ here's an article she wrote for them: Onward, Christian Soldiers
- Bender, Walter
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Questions: So how much money did the Irish government lose in the MIT Media Europe lark - and what was your role in it?
- Career: MIT Media Lab
- Background Info: His page at media labs. His personal page.
- Buzenberg, Bill
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Minnesota Public Radio
- Background Info:
- Bracken, John
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MacArthur Foundation
- Background Info:
- Cone, Ed
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: EdCone.com weblog (since 2002); opinion columnist, Greensboro News & Record; senior writer, Ziff Davis Media.
- Background Info: wrote in-depth case study of Dean campaign Internet strategy, 2003; former contributing editor, Wired; former staff writer, Forbes; moderator, blogging and journalism panel, BloggerCon, Oct. 2003; moderator, Campaign '04 session, BloggerCon III, Nov. 2004; Co-organizer of nation's first regional blogging conference, Greensboro, NC, 2004.
- Cox, Robert
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: The National Debate & Media Bloggers
- Background Info: Bio page: http://www.thenationaldebate.com/blog/archives/2005/01/bio_robert_cox.html
His comments on the conference blog commenters: I now see that the conference is being opened up on Saturday afternoon. I like the idea of having an informal wrap-up session but the idea that the people who have been flaming Rebecca are going to care is absurd. The type of people who make the kinds of comments recently made on this site are not people who often climb out from under their rock - let alone make their way to Cambridge - to engage in face-to-face philosophical debates with other human beings. They are primarily cowards, basking in the reflected anonymity of their Power Mac.
http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/webcred/index.php?p=28#comment-689
- Donath, Judith
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MIT Media Lab
- Background Info:
- Garcia, D. Linda
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Georgetown University
- Background Info:
- Giles, Bob
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Nieman Foundation
- Background Info:
- Gillmor, Dan
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Grassroots Journalism
- Background Info:
- Greeley, Brendan
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Public Radio Exchange.
- Background Info:
- Hinderaker, John
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Powerlineblog.com
- Background Info: Stopped here
- Holway, Edith
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Harvard Kennedy School, Shorenstein Ctr. on Press Politics & Public Policy
- Background Info:
- Im, Kathy
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MacArthur Foundation
- Background Info:
- Jackson, Brooks
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Factcheck.org
- Background Info:
- Jarvis, Jeff
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Buzz Machine
- Background Info:
- Jones, Alex
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Harvard Kennedy School, Shorenstein Ctr. on Press Politics & Public Policy
- Background Info:
- Kaplan, Rick
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MSNBC
- Background Info:
- Kennedy, Jim
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Associated Press
- Background Info:
- Lowe, Carrie
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: American Library Assoc. Office of Information Technology
- Background Info:
- Lydon, Chris
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Fellow, Public radio host, Bopnews, etc.
- Background Info:
- MacKinnon, Rebecca
- IRC Nick: RMack
- Contribution to conference: one organiser of several
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Center for Internet & Society, Harvard Law School
- Background Info:
- Marlow, Cameron
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MIT Media Lab, Blogdex.
- Background Info:
- Mitchell, Bill
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Poynter Institute
- Background Info:
- Nachison, Andrew
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: The Media Center @API
- Background Info:
- Palfrey, John
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Center for Internet & Society, Harvard Law School
- Background Info:
- Qiang, Xiao
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: China Digital News, Berkeley Grad School of Journalism
- Background Info:
- Rainie, Lee
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Pew Internet & American Life Project
- Background Info:
- Revere, Elspeth
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: MacArthur Foundation
- Background Info:
- Rosen, Jay
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: New York University
- Background Info: Stopped here.
- Rosenstiel, Tom
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Committee of Concerned Journalists (Jan21)
- Background Info: Stopped here.
- Schaffer, Jan
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: J-Lab: The Institute for Interactive Journalism
- Background Info:
- Schell, Orville
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkeley Grad School of Journalism
- Background Info:
- Schneider, Karen G.
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Freerangelibrarian
- Background Info:
- Shafer, Jack
- Sifry, David
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Technorati
- Background Info:
- Singer, Jane
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: University of Iowa
- Background Info:
- Teachout, Zephyr
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Ctr. for Internet & Society
- Background Info:
- Tifft, Susan
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Duke University
- Background Info:
- Trippi, Joe
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Trippi & Associates
- Background Info:
- Wales, Jimmy (Jimbo)
- Weinberger, David
- IRC Nick: joho
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Center for Internet & Society
- Background Info:
- Weingarten, Rick
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: American Library Institute, Office of Information Technology
- Background Info:
- Winer, Dave
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Scripting News
- Background Info:
- Zuckerman, Ethan
- IRC Nick: EthanZ
- Contribution to conference: one organiser of several
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Center for Internet & Society
- Background Info:
- Zittrain, Jonathan
- IRC Nick: unknown
- Contribution to conference: unknown
- Role in conference: unknown
- Career: Berkman Center for Internet & Society
- Background Info:
Outside Participation
The conference will have an audio stream. I'm not sure of the format or bandwidth requirements. I'm sure I fail at the latter, so I'll leave it to someone with broadband to research that.
The conference will "be on IRC," which is to say that there will be live transcription of the conference in one channel (#webcredtrans), and an IRC backchannel for discussion and posing questions to the speakers [-sj, the scribe].
Further questioning revealed that it will be on freenode's IRC network. No word on how it will be integrated into the conference. The participants page does not associate IRC nicknames with any of the conference participants. If any of them do log in, there's no way as yet to tell who is who. I've asked on the conference blog that they fix that. "/me holds breath..."
Questions Blog Readers and Writers Might Pose
- Why were no progressive bloggers invited to this conference? And why didn't any of you do anything to rectify this once this glaring lapse was pointed out?
- If at the end of the conference you come up with a set of ethical standards or codes of conduct, will you also publish a report card detailing how each of your invited participants scored?
- Considering the ethical lapses of modern journalism, don't you think this conference is seriously harmed by having journalists attempt to lecture (directly or indirectly) other fields on ethics?
- Can you folks ever come up with reasons for the hostility that this conference has generated that are not self-serving, are not couched in the language of victimisation and generally show some basic understanding that you have made grievous mistakes and that you'll actually try to fix them?
Conference Results
To be written at the end of the conference.
Further Research Required
This is a list of additional things that need to be researched. If you're working on it, please note that on this page. If you can think of additional things to look into, please do so.
- More Background Research
- Since I don't know any of these people I'm going to start by searching the Daily Howler archives for any articles there related to these people. (Kevin Lyda)
- Other ways to find background info on the participants? (help?)
- Clarify what the participants actually do. (help?)
![[Main Page]](../../../../upload/banner-blue-135.jpg)